Unobtrusive Pilot Response System

Howdy! I come to you today with a feature request that I promise you’ll be glad to have seen. Without further ado, I’ll get straight to the point.

Have you ever flown patterns at a controlled airfield? If so, you’re probably like me and have had a little trouble juggling talking to ATC and controlling your speed, altitude, flaps, gear, heading, etc. This is where my idea comes into play. Currently, you, as a pilot, have one of two options when replying to ATC:

  1. Option one is to tap on the lower left-hand corner headphone icon and press “REPLY.” This covers up the majority of your screen, especially on a phone, with a big black box. The box has only one thing you need to see! The relatively small “REPLY” button.

  1. Option two is by far the better option and very close to my idea. You can hold down the headphone icon for three seconds to send the same reply message you would if you follow option one. However, a few things are still missing, namely timeliness and familiarity. Maybe it’s just me but I didn’t know about this shortcut until just recently. As to timeliness, those three seconds really add up. One pattern calls for a pushback clearance, taxi clearance, takeoff clearance, sequencing, landing clearance, exit instruction, and a taxi to parking instruction. At the bare minimum! For one pattern! Now, if we choose, say ten patterns and we don’t repeat the use of pushback, taxi, takeoff, exit, and taxi to parking, we would have two instructions times ten, plus the five “one-time-use” instructions. This adds up to 25 total instructions, all of which require the pilot to reply! 25 instructions x 3 seconds per reply = 75 seconds of wasted time! For ten patterns! I think you get my point - time adds up.

I’m actually pretty curious how many of you all actually knew about option two. Here’s a poll to find out:

  • Yes, of course I knew about option two!
  • What?! Since when is that a thing?

0 voters

Now, for my feature: Option Three

  1. Instead of having a vague way to respond or having the response obtrude on our flying, why not have a “REPLY” button appear on screen, when needed. We would see it, quickly tap it to get rid of it, and continue our flight. My guess is this would take less than a second per reply. So, to recap, this solution is timely, familiar to all pilots, unobtrusive, easy to use, and simple.

Here are two mock-ups of my idea:

Mock-up credits: @Guxk and @Oli_H

If you somehow made it all the way to the bottom of the thread, thank you for your time. I hope you’ll consider voting for this, as it would help tons of pilots.

Again, thank you and safe flying!

This is a nice request. I can see how this would be nice to have for pilots. I’m out of votes, but I hope that this can be added into the game.

7 Likes

I agree this should be in the game, but now that I’m aware of that life-saving 3 second hold, I think that’s sufficient enough for now. Thank you so much for that tip!!!

2 Likes

That certainly backfired, didn’t it? :D Glad this topic was of some use to you.

1 Like

Very nice request thread. It’s clear you put a lot of thought and consideration into this; however, I personally feel that the current auto reply system is fast enough for most users and gives the same benefits as your reply button suggestion such as being unobtrusive. Hope the best for you.

1 Like

This is a great idea in my opinion, sadly I’m out of votes, despite supporting this idea a lot. ;)

1 Like

On the same page here. Out of votes. You have my full support here.

2 Likes

Thank you! I realize that this request is very similar to what we already have but why not make it better?

1 Like

Thanks for your support! :D

2 Likes

Is it just me or are the last 2 pictures the same???

Whenever tower tells me to exit runway when able I have to stop my reverse thrust to reply which gets annoying

2 Likes

Different themes I think

1 Like

I like this idea even when not doing patterns.

2 Likes

Yeah! It’s for all uses!