But you’re making that exact same logic error.
Your argument is that just by giving access to more people, regardless of their relative skill at the position, Realism™ is thereby achieved.
Your argument is Not B, Thus A.
That is just an enormous non sequitur. You still haven’t explained how Realism™ is improved by volume.
If you want to say “I’d like to access ATC but can’t afford Pro” that would be a logical statement. Trying to do mental gymnastics to claim that it improves the experience QED, you’re taking a logical leap that can’t be founded upon any of the rules of logic we’ve agreed upon for thousands of years.