I’ll be tower and graund Düsseldorf Int. for about an hour or so. Come on in and fly some patterns if you like. Feel free to leave your reviews and tips after.
Pay more attention to ground/ QR18 :)
Very nice. My aircraft selection was very unfortunate, considering all those winds (I was a Dash 8), but it was still good.
The only thing that I think you could improve is a bit of memory. Immediately after takeoff, you cleared me for the option. When I was turning base, you cleared me again. You don’t have to do that because I had already received clearance. Also that small error where you cleared me for a T&G instead of landing, and that you had cleared me for Lan gin before. Other than that, it was great!
Don’t say exit runway command when you are doing a touch and go:)
Since you already told me on takeoff make left traffic you don’t have to say “make left traffic” every time:) keep it up
Ok so you mean do not need every time say left and right traffic. Second round i will say just clear for option?
On takeoff: “QR18 cleared for takeoff, make left traffic” then if there’s another aircraft in the pattern: “QR18, number X traffic to follow on xxxxxxxxx” and when you clear me “QR18, cleared for the option” option: do what you want= fly by, touch and go, landing etc
Hey Khan. I was the A320 (N1YZ) doing patterns. a few things:
You did a good job with sequencing, but when someone is #1 in the pattern, you don’t need to issue any sequencing. Although you didn’t issue one to my on my pattern on 10R, you did for my pattern on 10L, and for @nicochile2 who I did notice called inbound after already being entered into the pattern through his takeoff command. The proper command to follow an inbound call is a pattern entry, but you used it in more than that occasion, and calling inbound while already in the pattern seems to be a TS1 thing anyways.
Although your landing clearances are great, and you correctly change the direct for runway changes without mistake, you don’t need to repeat a “After the Option, make (left/right) traffic” as long as you already cleared them for the option with that command, or you told them the direction when they requested takeoff, remaining in the pattern, and you don’t want to change their direction. Just clearing them for the option without that last part only means to turn in the direction they were told to go in their last pattern. Adding this command unnecessarily also clutters the frequency, which you never want. Secondly, I noticed you repeated many landing clearances, pattern entries, and sequencing calls over and over again, for no reason. Unless you need to change my runway or take me out of the pattern and re-sequence me, there is no reason to send multiple landing clearances, pattern entries, or sequencing commands on the same pattern. Unless you change or cancel my landing clearance, I will remained cleared to land until I touch down again, and either takeoff or taxi off the runway. In this case though, I would still suggest to wait to at least downwind before clearing, to make sure all your aircraft are sequenced the way you want and no one is going to mess things up to early.
When aircraft are too close together on downwind, base, or final, you can use multiple runways to help space things out, although on Tower, once sequenced, it is the pilot’s responsibility to make sure they are properly spaced before touch down (In real life and IF the Approach controller is responsible for this, and the pilot keeps himself properly spaced on his final approach, although IF has many more scenarios in which Approach is not available, but traffic levels could benefit greatly from it) You may have noticed that I was cutting it a bit close with the Dash-8 in front of my on my 3rd pattern on runway 10L. Normally, you would use a 360 for to aircraft close to each other that had just contacted you both from inbound, on a single-runway operation. In my case, it is really dangerous having a 360 on close final, with other aircraft that could be too close, causing them a 360, and so on, or on downwind and or base, causing a collision or close call, and the fact that the aircraft is too low. In that case then, you should have sent me a go around command, and resequenced me into the pattern. Always be ready to send aircraft around that couldn’t properly space themselves, or if they are close to the runway when another aircraft that landed hasn’t exited the runway yet, or if an aircraft you instructed to take off hasn’t left the ground yet. There should be no other traffic on the runway when a plane is about to land on it.
Transition is the last thing. If an aircraft is flying through your airspace (You can see this by clicking on the airport) then they would request a transition to know the minimum height they should be flying over your airport to avoid traffic. This should usually be 2500-5000 ft above the airport AGL so the one you sent is a on the low side.
If you want any more help feel free to contact me, and I’ll be happy to help out, as I am an Official Trainer and Tester for the IFATC
(Sorry about this late response. Novel to write. If something is confusing just ask an I’ll clarify it for you :)
are you some kind of trainer of the air traffic control side of IF??
As he mentioned. 👍🏻
Thanks man I didn’t really look at the message I looked like he wrote a lot so I just jumped to conclusions
No worries mate, if your ever looking for our training team here’s the topic;
Thank you very much @Zachary_Meir_Tish for taking the time to write such a good explanation. I answer late because I’m not so good at writing english …I kept reading your comment
And it’s nice to hear that you’re training and ready to help, we’ll be sure to ask you questions about atc🙂
I have a question now
how do I know which aircraft are allowed and which is not allowed to an airport I am atc control
When you click the airport, it should say that it is class “bravo”, or “charlie”, “delta”, etc. Bravo airfields can have all types of aircraft. Also you could use common sense. There are many class bravo airports that just can’t hold a 747.
Can you send meg photo for better understand? Please
And how to get to know my airport airspace for (transition)
Just select an airport, like KFLL. Same place where you check who is controlling, or airport elevation, etc.
There you go. I believe it changes depending on what “ring” the aircraft is flying through.