How can we practice ATC in the training server when nobody listens and just does their own things. At some points the ATC is just talking to themselves and can’t even report people who are ruining the training server for others trying to listen and communicate with ATC.
Hello, yes this is a frustrating situation. If you want real ATC control rules, you can join IFATC.
Try the ATCMH. Organized ATC sessions with staff trained to keep an environment friendly for learning. We do have to run the sessions on Training Server but the selection of airports is designed to avoid random pilots as much as possible.
People kept spamming, taking off/landing without permission, and someone even flew through my ATC tower. I do think ATC training server should be able to issue Level 1 vios
This is why people make ATC tracking threads, allowing people who want to help you learn, come and fly at less busy airports. If you want to have a real ATC experience, don’t open a random busy airport like LAX or LHR.
The problem with ATC issuing violations on the training server is that the same trolls who are not listening to your instructions would then start controlling and spamming every pilot with violations. It would be awful, and no one would ever fly on the training server
Will give this a go and join! Thanks so much!
Had the same at EGLL today. Was the only controller for ground and tower (had to switch to just ground after a while cause of volume) but people taking off/ landing as they wish, taxi through buildings, not going around etc. just frustrating when some pilots are following and it’s not helpful for both the pilots and atc.
That makes sense about the violations aspect. Got notifications on for the ATC threads so will give that a go too.
So fundamentally is there any difference between ATC-controlled airports in the training vs expert server?
Yes. In the expert server, users obey (for the most part
) the directives of the IFATC members. Also, if you don’t, you can receive a level 2 or 3 violation from the controlling member, putting you out of action temporarily. In the training server, there are no repercussions for disobeying ATC instructions.
Got it so I could potentially get away with violations in the training server but not in expert server? This helps because I am 1 violation away from being downgraded from Expert to Training this year! I think the best thing to do is to avoid flying in ATC-controlled airports haha
Well, you could potentially avoid any more violations on the training server but it’s a bit messy on the training server with some pilots doing random things. Yeah, maybe be a bit more cautious in expert servers, especially in ATC areas.
Well, getting away with violations is the wrong way to think about it. Rather, consider avoiding congested ATC areas, and make sure you understand the rules. Violations are given for breaking the rules, so at a certain point, one shouldn’t have any worry about getting one since they fully understand the rules. If one is wrongly given, then an appeal will be successful and the violation removed!
Gotcha, sounds great! Thanks for that tip!
You should join IFATC! In order to prepare for the practical, IFATC as well as ATCMH offer trainers who will help you develop your Ground/Tower skills.
But for joining IFATC it needs 500 ATC Operations. How to do that when nobody is listening and airports are always full for ATC in training server so I don’t get any chance to do any operations.
At crowded airports like EGLL, this is possible. Some pilots may listen, some may not (they may not follow instructions), but if you give the instructions and the pilot responds, this counts as an operation for you.
That’s why you create a tracking thread for yourself via the ATC channel. If you go there now and check it out, you’ll see other users’ threads. This allows you to open smaller airports where you can have people come help you practice, and avoid the chaos of the “hub” airports. If you’re looking to train, absolutely do NOT open EGLL.
I have 450 operations done already. I have sufficient training to how to manage ground and Air Traffic. But the problem is as always airports like EGLL, OMDB are always full for ATC. And if I get the opportunity to become ATC very few pilots listen to ATC.
Exactly. That is why I advise opening a tracking thread and operate at obscure or less trafficked airports, as this will give you a better opportunity to practice air traffic control!